Laughing Boy and Lumberjack 😆🪓

No, this isn’t a new superhero double act, “Laughing Boy and Lumberjack” is an extended, three-phase handling of Dr. Daley’s Last Trick. This variation was inspired by a favourite routine of mine called “Transmutation” by George McBride. The trick combines Ambitious Card, Dr. Daley’s Last Trick and the surprise ending from the Roy Walton classic, “Oil and Queens”. That’s a whole lot of magic in a single packet trick!

The presentation takes inspiration from the fascinating history behind the Joker, the trick-taking card game of Euchre (pronounced yew-ker), and the old American folk song “Jack of Diamonds”, also known as “Rye Whiskey”.

“Rye Whiskey” sung by Jake Book. Video Credit: Trask McFarland via YouTube.

Effect

You begin by displaying four playing cards. You tell your audience that they’re the Jack of Clubs, Hearts, Spades, and Diamonds. But it’s evident to everyone that they’re four identical Jokers, not Jacks. A fact your audience is keen to point out to you.

You explain that the Joker was invented to be the “Best Bower” when playing the card game of Euchre. The best bower, you say, is capable of beating the two highest trump cards—the two red or black Jacks, known as the Right and Left Bowers. So, in a way, the Joker is “a glorified Jack.”

You also tell your audience that when poker players adopted the Joker, it became a “wild card,” used to represent any card in the deck. You deal one Joker to the table. Rubbing it against the tabletop, you recite a verse from an old American folk song:

“Jack o’ Diamonds, Jack o’ Diamonds, I’ve known you of old. You’ve robbed my poor pockets of silver and gold.”

When you turn the card over, it is the Jack of Diamonds! You flick another Joker, and it visibly morphs into the Jack of Hearts!

You explain that the two cards are “jumping Jacks” and offer to demonstrate what you mean. You place the Jack of Diamonds underneath the two remaining Jokers. You tap the packet, and the Jack of Diamonds magically jumps to the top. You deal the card to the table and repeat the same action with the Jack of Hearts, which also rises to the top.

Next, you simplify things by removing the two Jokers from proceedings. You deal the Jack of Hearts on top of the Jack of Diamonds. You tap the two cards, then turn the top one over to reveal that the Jack of Diamonds has once again risen to the top.

You offer to repeat the feat. You return the Jack of Diamonds to the table and put the Jack of Hearts on top of it again. This time, you instruct a spectator to put her finger on top of the two cards (to prevent you from using sleight of hand).

You hold the two Jokers in your hand. You tap the top of your packet. Amazingly, the top card is turned face up to reveal the Jack of Diamonds. Flipping over the bottom card reveals it to be the Jack of Hearts. An impossible transposition has taken place!

Finally, the cards under the spectator’s finger are turned over to reveal two black Jacks! All four Jokers have transformed into Jacks, bringing the trick full circle.

Background & Credits

This routine takes inspiration from “The Last Trick of Dr. Jacob Daley” by Dr. Jacob Daley (1957, The Dai Vernon Book of Magic) and “Transmutation” by George McBride (2002, The Best of Osmosis). It combines elements of Wild Card with Ambitious Card, Dr. Daley’s Last Trick, and Roy Walton’s “Oil and Queens” (specifically the kicker ending).

The presentation is inspired by the supposed origin of the Joker playing card, the rules of the card game Euchre, and the traditional American folk song “Jack of Diamonds” or “Rye Whiskey”, which is thought to date back to the time of the Civil War in the United States (1861–1865). It goes by many alternative names and is related to similar songs which share the same basic melody, such as “Drunken Hiccups”, “Clinch Mountain”, and “O Molly”. It is thought that some of the lyrics might be derived from the popular Civil War song “The Rebel Soldier”. A version of “Jack of Diamonds” was featured in the video game Red Dead Redemption 2 (2018, Rockstar Games).

Requirements & Preparation

Remove the four Jacks and a single Joker from a regular pack of playing cards. Arrange the cards in the following order, with the Joker at the face: JH-JS-JC-JD-Joker. Put them in a pocket, wallet or envelope.

Method & Presentation

There are three phases to the routine. In the first, two of the Jokers transform into the red Jacks. In the second, a short Ambitious Card sequence is performed with the two Jokers and Jacks. During the final phase, the Jacks transpose with the Jokers, then the Jokers transform into the two black Jacks.

Phase 1: Jokers to Jacks

Remove the packet from the wallet or envelope and perform a brisk Flushtration Count. As you apparently display each card (by turning your right hand palm up), name each Jack in turn. In other words, as you complete the false count, say, “Here I have the Jack of Clubs, Jack of Hearts, Jack of Spades, and, last but not least, the Jack of Diamonds.” Hold a little finger break below the last two cards. Wait for a member of your audience to object and tell you that the cards are all Jokers, not Jacks. Children are usually particularly keen to point out your apparent mistake!

By naming the four Jacks aloud while displaying what appear to be four identical Jokers, you’re psychologically strengthening the Flushtration Count—a display that some magicians believe to be weak and unconvincing. This approach is very disarming and subtly reinforces the false count by making people think, “Hey, they’re not Jacks! They’re Jokers.” Instead of the performer telling his audience that he’s holding four Jokers, something that might naturally arouse suspicion, your spectators tell themselves that the cards are all Jokers. Of course, this psychological subtlety can also be used with a diminishing lift sequence, if you really don’t want to rely on a Flushtration Count (see Performance Tips & Additional Ideas).

You explain that the Joker, “used to be called the ‘Best Bower’ and was introduced into the deck when the game of Euchre first became popular in the American Old West.” The best bower, you explain, is capable of beating the two highest trump cards—the two red or black Jacks, known as the Right and Left Bowers. So, in a way, you continue, the Joker is, “a glorified Jack.”

Perform a double turnover (easy because of the break) to display a Joker. Repeat the turnover and deal the top card of the packet (the Jack of Diamonds) to the table. Rub the card against the surface of the table as you say, “Now, watch closely as I recite these words from an old American folk song: Jack o’ Diamonds, Jack o’ Diamonds, I’ve known you of old. You’ve robbed my poor pockets of silver and gold.”

Flip the card over to reveal the Joker has transformed into the Jack of Diamonds. Display the face of the card to your audience, as you say, “Behold! The Jolly Joker has revealed his true nature—the Jack o’ Diamonds. Or, as the gamblers of the Old West called him, the Laughing Boy. I don’t know why he earned himself this mischievous moniker—if you ask me, he has a pretty serious-looking expression on his face! However, in some variations of blackjack and poker, players must chuckle every time the Jack of Diamonds is played or drawn.”

Continue by telling your audience that, “the Jack of Diamonds embodies the pleasures and pitfalls associated with the lifestyle of the wandering cowboy. Here’s my favourite verse from the song: If the river were whiskey, and I were a duck, I’d dive to the bottom and never come up. But the river ain’t whiskey, and I ain’t no duck, so I’ll play Jack o’ Diamonds, and trust in my luck.”

Establish a left little finger break above the bottom card of the packet using a buckle or pinky pulldown. Then, casually slip cut the top card of the packet into the break as you say, “Now, let’s see if we can conjure up Laughing Boy’s brother, the Jack of Hearts.”

Next, perform a triple turnover to apparently display another Joker on top of the packet. To visually transform the face-up Joker into the Jack of Hearts, perform Marc DeSouza’s Shapeshifter Change on the whole packet, as follows: 

Holding the cards in an elevated left-hand mechanic’s grip, rotate the packet to your left by moving your left thumb to your right. Regrip the packet from above with your palm-down right hand. The cards should be held between your right thumb and second finger, the pad of the thumb contacting the inner right hand corner and the tip of your second finger resting on the outer right hand corner of the packet. Apply a gentle pressure to the cards so that they bow upward. Next, reposition the thumb and second finger of your left hand, so that the pad of the thumb is against the outer left-hand corner and the tip of your second finger is positioned on the inner right-hand corner of the packet. You’re now ready to perform the Shapeshifter Change.

To activate the colour change, flex the packet a couple of times by applying downward pressure on it with the thumb and second finger of your left hand and, at the same time, gently pulling up with your right hand. On the third flex, apply more pressure with your left second finger and thumb and, as the packet bends, release your left-hand’s grip on the cards. Done correctly, this should cause the packet to rapidly rotate one hundred and eighty degrees. As soon as the packet has finished rotating, lower the cards into your left hand.

Situation Check: After the Shapeshifter Change, you will be left with the Jack of Hearts face up on top of a face-down packet of three cards: the two black Jacks and the Joker. The Joker is on the bottom of the packet.

Perform a Mini Ascanio Spread, displaying the four cards as three, and say, “Look! The Jack of Hearts, known in the Old West as the Lumberjack because he’s the only Jack wielding an axe. The card symbolises youthful love and passion.”

Hand the Jack of Hearts to your participant, or drop it to the table, so that they can examine the card. 

Carefully sidejog the top card of the three-card packet to apparently display two cards in your left hand. Regrip the packet between the thumb and finger of your right hand, thumb on top and fingers below. Flick the two (?) cards with your left thumb. Then, without squaring the cards, flip the packet face up bookwise into a left-hand mechanic’s grip. The cards should naturally coalesce as the edge of the packet hits the second, third and little finger of your left hand.

This casual two-card display and turnover isn’t necessary, but it helps to clarify that you have two Jokers (?) and two red Jacks before you move onto phase two of the routine.

Situation Check: The Jack of Diamonds and Jack of Hearts are face up on the table. In your hand are three cards: the two black Jacks and the Joker (the face card of the packet).

Phase 2: Jumping Jacks

Once your participant has had a good look at the two red Jacks, say, “The Laughing Boy and Lumberjack are jumping Jacks. Let me show you what I mean.”

Take back the Jack of Diamonds and, as you display the card to your audience, establish a break above the bottom card of the packet. Slide the Jack into the break, leaving it outjogged by about half an inch. Next, contact the top card of the packet with the fingertips of your right hand, outjogging it by half an inch.

This vertical spread provides compelling proof that the Jack has been placed on the bottom of the packet (?). Your left thumb and fingers hide the extra thickness of the packet.

Square up the spread. Tap the top of the packet with your right first finger (or perform another magical gesture), and then perform a triple turnover to apparently display the Jack of Diamonds on top.

Repeat the turnover, then immediately deal the top card to the table, next to the face-up Jack of Hearts. Next, perform a Flushtration Count, displaying the three cards as two by dropping the last two cards as one on top of the packet. This false count does two things: it gives the impression that you hold two Jokers, but it also reinforces the idea that the face-down card on the table is the Jack of Diamonds.

Take the Jack of Hearts and repeat the Ambitious Card sequence in exactly the same way as before. Turn the triple face down and deal the top card of the packet, apparently the Jack of Hearts, on top of the face-down card already on the table. 

Tap the two cards and turn the top one face up, displaying the Jack of Diamonds on top of the pile. Pick both cards up and drop them on top of the cards in your left hand. Push over the top card, the face-up Jack of Diamonds, and take it in your right hand. Perform a triple turnover to display the Jack of Hearts below the Jack of Diamonds. Replace the Jack of Diamonds on top of the left-hand packet, injogging it by about half an inch.

Situation Check: From the top of the packet down, the cards are in the following order: JD-JH-Joker-JC-JS. All cards are face up, apart from the Jack of Spades on the bottom of the packet.

Phase 3: Transpose and Transform

Turn to your participant and say, “Shall we do that again?” This is a rhetorical question. Regardless of what they reply, you’re going to continue on! Square up the cards and establish a break above the bottom card of the packet with your left little finger. Regrip the packet in right-hand end grip, transferring the break to your right thumb.

You’re now going to perform a slick switch of the Jack of Diamonds for the bottom card of the packet (one of the black Jacks). With your left thumb, peel off the Jack of Diamonds into your left hand, using the cards remaining in your right hand to lever the Jack face down.

Move your left hand under the right-hand packet and secretly deposit the card below the break on top of the Jack of Diamonds. Use your right fingers and thumb to square the two cards, making sure that they’re perfectly aligned. Immediately turn your left hand palm up to quickly flash the face of the Jack to your audience. Finally, replace the double under the three cards held in your right hand, making sure that it is outjogged by approximately half an inch.

To switch the Jack, perform the Christ/Annemann Alignment move on the packet. Spin the outjogged card out from under the packet and casually drop it to the table.

Transfer the cards in right-hand end grip into your left hand. Call attention to the face-up Jack of Hearts on top of the packet and say, “As soon as I drop the Lumberjack on top of Laughing Boy, place your finger on top of the two cards. This will prevent me from doing any sneaky sleight of hand.”

Perform a triple turnover, then take the top card and drop it on top of the card already on the table.

Casually thumb the top card of the packet you hold to the bottom, then perform another three-as-two Flushtration Count to display two Jokers (?). Tap the top of your packet and immediately push the top card to your right with your left thumb. With your palm-down right hand, turn the card over stud style. Next, clip the double card remaining in your left hand between the face-up Jack of Diamonds and your right fingertips. Use your right fingers to flip the double card over, displaying the Jack of Hearts below the Jack of Diamonds. Smile at your audience and say, “I told you they were jumping Jacks!”

It’s now time to reveal the two black Jacks. Say, “If I have Laughing Boy and Lumberjack, you must have…” Perform another Flushtration Count to display the two red Jacks while hiding the Joker. Let your participant finish your sentence by saying, “...the two Jokers.” Wait for them to lift their hand and turn the two cards over to reveal the black Jacks. Bring the routine to a satisfying conclusion by saying, “I told you those Jokers were just glorified Jacks!”

Cleanup & Reset

As your audience reacts to the kicker ending, establish a little finger break above the bottom card of the packet. Cut the two cards above the break, as one, to the bottom of the packet. Immediately perform a Gambler’s Cop to steal away the Joker. Either ditch the card in your jacket or trouser pocket, or lap it if seated. As you perform the cop, gently throw the two red Jacks onto the table. The forward motion of the cards will give you ample cover to steal the Joker and hide it from your audience.

If, however, you’d rather reset the cards for a future performance, flip the two red Jacks (?) face down and then drop the black Jacks on top of the cards in your hand. Establish a little finger break above the bottom card of the packet. Cut all the cards above the break to the bottom. The packet is now reset for your next performance and can be returned to the wallet or envelope it came from.

Performance Tips & Additional Ideas

It is possible to start the routine with a diminishing lift sequence to display the four Jokers. To do this, you’ll need to arrange the cards in a different starting order, as follows: JC-JD-JH-JS-Joker. 

First, perform a Jordan Count to display the five cards as four. Block turnover  the top four cards to display a Joker on top of the packet. Repeat the turnover, then thumb the top card into your right hand. Next, perform another turnover, this time of three cards. Rather than making this more difficult, the single card held in your right hand makes this move easier because it provides some natural cover for the turnover. As the edge of the left-hand packet is covered by the card, perform a Pinky Pulldown on the bottom card of the packet to form a break. Insert the fingers of your right hand into the break and immediately flip all the cards above the break over as a block. Repeat the turnover, then take the top card of the left-hand packet above the card already held in your right hand. Perform two more block turnovers in the same way, then slide the top card of the left-hand packet above the two being held in your right hand, being careful to keep the two cards remaining in your left hand together as one (slightly squeezing the cards with the fingers and thumb of your left hand helps). 

Finally, slide the double card on top of those in your right hand, then reposition the cards in left-hand mechanic’s grip. Immediately flip over a single card to display a fourth and final Joker. Flip the Joker face down, regrip the packet from above in right-hand end grip, then rapidly reverse count the packet into your left hand, dropping the last two cards as one. If you’ve managed to follow this sequence correctly, the cards should be in JH-JS-JC-JD-Joker order. You can now perform the trick as outlined above. Don’t immediately perform the Flushtration Count. Wait, talk to your audience, then perform the false count. In this scenario, the Flushtration Count is acting as a secondary convincer that all the cards are Jokers, so there’s no need to call a lot of attention to the display.

Personally, I think that the Flushtration Count is strong enough when apparently displaying four cards that are all alike. However, if I were performing the trick for a fellow magician or on video, I’d definitely use the diminishing lift sequence. For me, the visual pop of the Shapeshifter Change compliments the the slower, and more cerebral change that happens before it (the Joker transforming into the Jack of Diamonds). The first change happens when the card is face down, and the second takes it up a notch and takes place with the card remaining face up.

I love Marc DeSouza’s Shapeshifter Change. It works particularly well when performed on an entire packet of cards. However, you can substitute the Twirl Change or Vernon’s Variant Through the Fist Flourish, if you prefer.

Another interesting idea is to allow someone to name the trump suit as if they were actually playing a game of Euchre. You can borrow a method to do this from a variation of a Jay Sankey trick of mine called “Shake It Up”. The routine uses Kings, but you’ll see that the exact same setup and handling can be used to turn the first Joker into any of the four Jacks. Once you’ve done this, you’ll need to displace the top card of the packet to the bottom before performing the triple turnover and Shapeshifter Change. Doing this will ensure that the Jack of the same colour, but the opposite suit to the named trump will be produced (what is known as the “Left Bower” in Euchre). For example, if a spectator names the Spade as the trump suit, then the card transformed using the Shapeshifter Change will be the Jack of Clubs. 

This idea moves the presentation away from the memorable “Laughing Boy and Lumberjack” hook used above, but would be a smart choice when performing the trick for someone who actually plays Euchre. This trick-taking card game is not very common in the UK and Europe, but I’ve heard it’s still very popular in midwest America, Michigan, in particular. In fact, Michigan Radio declared the Mitten State “the buckle of the Euchre belt,” which includes Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio and Pennsylvania. The game is also hugely popular in Canada, specifically Ontario.

Final Thoughts

“Laughing Boy and Lumberjack” is an impressive and memorable multiphase version of Dr. Daley’s Last Trick. However, if you prefer handlings of this plot that only use four cards, then I strongly recommend that you learn “Transmutation” by George McBride.

At some point in the future, I’d like to explore the idea of incorporating some coin magic into this routine. It would be really cool to produce silver and gold coins and then make them disappear by passing the Jack of Diamonds over them while saying, “You robbed my poor pockets of silver and gold.” Perhaps a Raven could be used to achieve this.

The Raven being used to vanish four coins. Photo Credit: Pengiun Magic.

Comments