Paradox of Love ❤
This romantic packet trick draws inspiration from a counter-intuitive adage by Elbert Hubbard, an acclaimed American writer, publisher, artist, and philosopher, who wrote:
“The love you give away is the only love you keep.”
Hubbard, a self-proclaimed anarchist and a socialist, was an influential figure in the Arts and Crafts movement, founding the Roycroft artisan community in East Aurora, New York. Echoing the creative spirit of Hubbard’s collective, I took a more experimental approach to the development of this trick. I decided to create an effect that suited the presentation rather than starting with an existing effect and devising a presentation to fit it. My goal was to bring the “paradox of love” to life using the art of sleight of hand and a deck of playing cards, a process that was both challenging yet deeply rewarding.
While this may not be the final version of the trick, I’m sharing it to encourage others to explore and refine it. The universal appeal of this plot offers ample opportunity for creative interpretation, and I look forward to seeing how it evolves in the hands of other magicians.
JUMP AHEAD
On This Page
Effect
Background & Credits
Requirements & Preparation
Method & Presentation
Cleanup & Reset
Performance Tips & Additional Ideas
Final Thoughts
Footnotes
Effect
You begin by explaining that your deck is unique, containing three identical Jokers instead of the usual two. The three Jokers are dealt to the table, and the rest of the deck is set aside.
You start your performance by discussing the wisdom of Elbert Hubbard and his famous aphorisms, such as “A friend is someone who knows all about you and still loves you.” Then, share your favourite quote of his:
“There can be no art without love, and the love you keep is the love you liberate in your work.”
You tell your audience that Hubbard’s views on love are similar to what modern psychologists call the “paradox of love”, a concept you offer to explain through the performance of a card trick.
The Jokers are displayed one at a time, and then, with a graceful flick, one of the cards is transformed into the Ace of Hearts. This card is given to a spectator to hold, as you explain, “The paradox of love states that the love you give away is the only love you keep.”
Next, the remaining two Jokers are also transformed into Aces of Hearts, as you comment, “Love is a strange currency; if you give it away, you actually end up having more!”
Continuing the performance, you state, “In fact, love only grows if you give it away.” As you speak these words, your participant turns over their card, revealing it has changed into the Ten of Hearts! Finish by displaying all three cards and saying, “We now have ten, eleven, twelve Hearts in total. That’s a whole lotta love!”
For the finale, you transform all three cards—the two Aces of Hearts and the Ten of Hearts—back into Jokers, completing the magical journey of love’s paradox.
Background & Credits
“Paradox of Love” was inspired by the writings of Elbert Hubbard and the lyrics of a song I used to sing at primary school called “Magic Penny” by Malvina Reynolds, an American folk and blues singer-songwriter (like Hubbard, she was also an activist). 1 You can hear Malvina sing the song on YouTube:
| Malvina Reynolds singing “Magic Penny”. Video Credit: Malvina Reynolds via YouTube. |
The routine incorporates the following sleight-of-hand techniques, as summarised below:
- The Braue Addition: It was created by Frederick Braue and first published in its modern form in Hugard’s Magic Monthly (Vol. 3, No. 2, July 1945, page 135). Ed Marlo also claimed the move, suggesting it was leaked to Braue before he was able to publish it himself (whether this is true or not is debatable).
- The Flushtration Count: This false count was originally described in print by Norm Houghton in Ibidem (No. 1, June 1955, page 8). Brother John Hamman popularised this technique and is, therefore, often mistakenly credited with its invention.
- The Tres Arriba Count: Invented by R. Paul Wilson and published as part of his routine “Gypsy Monte” on his Knock ‘Em Dead DVDs (Meir Yedid Magic, 1999).
- The Double Turnover: This is a classic sleight used in many card routines.
- The Shapeshifter Change: Developed by Marc DeSouza and based on Oscar Munoz’s The Pirouette Change. Both changes were first published in Steve Beam’s Trapdoor magazine, Issue #48, in 1993.
These methods form the foundation of this trick’s methodology.
Requirements & Preparation
You’ll need three identical Jokers in your deck to perform the main routine as described. However, you can also perform the trick with a single Joker or, better yet, a single blank-faced playing card. These alternative approaches are described below (see Performance Tips & Additional Ideas).
Method & Presentation
Run through the pack and remove the three Jokers. As you do so, surreptitiously position the Ten of Hearts on top of the deck with the Ace of Hearts directly below it. If you can cull cards, you can secretly move these two cards to the top as you spread through the pack and remove the three Jokers.
As your audience examines the Jokers, say, “This deck is odd because it contains three Jokers. Most only have two.”
Take back the three Jokers, and drop the face-up cards on top of the face-down deck. Spread through the cards to display the Jokers. As you square up, establish a little finger break below the top five cards of the pack. Perform a standard Braue Addition to switch out two of the Jokers for the Ace and Ten of Hearts.
The Braue Addition: Here’s how you perform a standard Braue Addition. Lift all five cards above the break off the deck (in right-hand end grip) and move them to your right. As you do this, contact the top card of the packet with your left thumb, pulling it back onto the deck and leaving it sidejogged. Use the block of cards in your right hand to flip the card face down. Do exactly the same thing with the next card. As soon as this card is face down, drop all the cards remaining in your right hand, as one, on top of the deck. Push the face-up card to the right with your left thumb and flip it face down with the aid of your right fingers and thumb. Done as one smooth continuous motion, the Braue Addition is a very deceptive switch.
Deal the top three cards of the deck to the table into a single, face-down pile.
Situation Check: The pile on the table contains a Joker, the Ten of Hearts and the Ace of Hearts (the Ace is the top card of the pile). The other two Jokers are face down on top of the deck.
Discard the talon, pick up the three-card pile, and perform a Flushtration Count to apparently display three Jokers. Immediately follow this with R. Paul Wilson’s Tres Arriba Count, leaving the top Joker face up at the conclusion of the count.
You don’t have to perform the Tres Arriba Count. After performing the Flustration Count, you can just flip the top card over. However, performing the Tres Arriba Count gives you more time to talk about the Jokers and how they’re often used as “wild cards” or to replace missing cards in a deck. It also strengthens the illusion that you have three Jokers and puts more “distance” between the deck and the first magical effect (transforming a Joker into the Ace of Hearts).
The Tres Arriba Count: Flip the top card of the packet (the Joker) face up. Turn it face down, take the two top cards as one, and transfer them to the bottom of the packet. Next, perform a double turnover to display the face of the Joker for a second time. Repeat the double turnover, then move the top card to the bottom of the packet, matching, as closely as possible, the way you did it before. Finally, flip the top card over to display the Joker for a third time to complete the count.
Ask your audience, “Have you ever heard of the ‘Paradox of Love’?” Whatever response you receive, say, “Let me demonstrate the concept by performing a card trick for you. Watch the Joker on top of the packet.”
Perform Marc DeSousa’s Shapeshifter Change to visibly transform the face-up Joker into the Ace of Hearts. If you prefer, you can perform a Twirl Change or a Through the Fist Flourish Change (any transformation that involves secretly turning the entire packet over will work).
Situation Check: The face-up Ace of Hearts is on top of the packet. Below it is the face-up Ten of Hearts, and below that is the face-down Joker.
Perform a double turnover, placing the top card of the packet into the spectator’s hand, as you say, “The paradox of love states that the love you give away is the only love you keep.”
Next, perform a Flushtration Count on the two cards remaining in your hand to display two Jokers (?). Immediately repeat the Flushtration Count to show them as two Aces, as you say, “Love is a strange currency; if you give it away, you end up having more!”
Although passé for magicians, this sequence is startling to the uninitiated. The three Jokers have each transformed into the Ace of Hearts in a most convincing manner.
Wait for the triple transformation to register with your audience, then say, “In fact, love will only grow if you give it away.” As you speak these words, instruct your participant to turn over their card, revealing it has changed into the Ten of Hearts!
Take the Ten back and, if you’re able, spin the card on your finger before flipping it face down on top of the two cards in your left hand.
Reverse count the three cards, then perform a double turnover to display an Ace of Hearts on top of the packet. Repeat the turnover, taking the top card in your right hand. Use it to flip the top card of the pair remaining in your left hand face up to display another Ace (?). Take this card underneath the one already in your right hand. Finally, use the fingers and thumb of your left hand to flip the Ten over. Place this card, still face up, on top of those in your right hand.
Replace the cards in left-hand dealer’s grip and square up. Immediately regrip the packet in right-hand end grip. Using the thumb of your left hand, pull the Ten back into your left hand, allowing it to rotate face-down as it falls. Perform one final Flushtration Count on top of the Ten. Finish this phase of the trick by saying, “We now have ten, eleven, twelve Hearts. That’s a whole lotta love!”
Situation Check: You hold three cards: the Ace of Hearts, Joker and Ten of Hearts. The Ace is the top card of the packet.
Establish a little finger break above the bottom card of the packet and openly slip cut the top card of the packet (the Ace of Hearts) into the break. Immediately perform another double turnover to display an Ace of Hearts on top. Repeat the turnover, and then take the top card of the packet in your right hand. Keeping this card face down, flip the two remaining in your left hand face up to display the Ten and Ace of Hearts.
Drop the card in your right hand to the table (or into your participant’s hand), allowing it to flip face up in the process. One of the Aces has apparently transformed back into a Joker.
Drop the two cards you still hold on top of the Joker, pick up the three face-up cards and place them on top of the deck. Spread over the top few cards to display the Ten, Ace and Joker, as you say, “I can’t leave these two cards as an Ace and a Ten. Otherwise, I’ll have two of each in the deck.”
Square up the deck and create a small break with your little finger under the top five cards. This will prepare you for another Braue Addition. After performing the switch, immediately riffle the cards, which serves as your magical gesture. Then, take the top card off the deck and snap it as you do so. Drop it onto the table, allowing it to flip face up as it falls. Repeat this process with the other two Jokers to reveal, to the audience’s surprise, that all three cards have returned to their original state.
Cleanup & Reset
The only evidence of the method left at the end of the routine is the Ace and Ten of Hearts on top of the deck. As your participant examines the three Jokers, shuffle the top two cards to the bottom of the deck. Then, using your left fingertips, retain the Ace of Hearts on the bottom as you shuffle off. Finally, give the pack a complete cut. This sequence separates the Ace and the Ten, losing them in random positions in the deck and destroying any evidence of the method.
Performance Tips & Additional Ideas
This is the perfect packet trick to perform for a a husband and wife or any couple who are romantically involved. It would also make an excellent trick to perform as a piece of strolling magic at a wedding. If you do perform “Paradox of Love” for a couple, I recommend asking one of the participants to give their card to their partner before it transforms into the Ten of Hearts.
It’s entirely possible to perform this trick as a stand-alone packet trick. Put the cards in the following order: Ace of Hearts, Ten of Hearts, Joker. The Joker should be the face card of the packet.
Perform the trick as described above. When you get to the part where you must perform the second Braue Addition, place the Joker on top of the Ace and Ten of Hearts. Give the packet a shake and then perform the following three-as-three false count:
Hold the packet in a left-hand fingertip grip. Take the Joker in right-hand dealer’s grip on the count of one. As the right hand returns to your left, slide the Joker under the packet and take the top two cards, the Ace and the Ten, in your right hand, leaving the Joker in left-hand fingertip grip. Finally, take the Joker on top of the Ten in your right hand. This false count hides the Ace by displaying the Joker twice and is very convincing if performed without hesitation and with a slight downward snap of the cards.
Perform the Alignment Move, outjogging the Ten without exposing the Ace behind it. Spin it out of the packet with the aid of your right hand and drop it on the face of the packet. Turn the entire packet face down and perform a double turnover to display a Joker on top of the packet. Repeat the turnover, then deal the top card to the table. Simulating your double turnover, turn the Joker face up, then face down again. Deal it on top of the card already on the table. Finally, casually drop the Ten on top of the pile, allowing it to flip face up in the process.
Pick up the entire packet, and perform the Shapeshifter Change to transform the Ten back into a Joker. Finally, perform another Tres Arriba Count to display three Jokers (?).
To reset the trick, reverse count the cards and put them back in your pocket (or vanish the packet). You will need a line to cover replacing the cards, something like, “And that’s why you should always remove the Jokers from the deck before you play cards with a magician!” This line of dialogue prevents people from asking to look at the cards.
The disadvantage of this approach is that there’s a lot of heat on the three cards once you change them back into three Jokers. So much so that it might be wise to switch them somehow, e.g., have a duplicate set of three Jokers in a Himber or Z-Fold Wallet; this is why I prefer the handling that uses the Braue Addition.
If you intend to perform this as a stand-alone packet trick, you might as well add an additional kicker ending. Here’s a fairly easy way to transform all three cards into the Ten of Hearts. To do this, you need three duplicate Ten of Hearts, one Ace of Hearts and one Joker. Arrange the card in the following order from the top of the packet: 10H-10H-AH-10H-J. The Joker should be the face card of the packet.
As you remove the packet of cards from your pocket, thumb off the two top cards, leaving them hidden in your pocket. Perform the trick (as described above) up until the point at which the Ace of Hearts transforms into the Ten of Hearts. As your audience reacts to this moment of magic, reverse count the two cards in your hand so that the Ace is on the bottom and the Joker is on top. Then, casually dip both hands into your jacket pockets, placing the two cards in your hand on top of the two Tens already in there as you relax and step backwards.
As you remove the cards from your pocket, thumb off the top card (the Joker) and leave it in your pocket. Openly displace the top card of the packet to the bottom. Now, call attention to your cards as you perform a Flushtration Count, holding the last two cards as one. This false count gives the strong impression that you’re holding two duplicate Ace of Hearts.
To transform the cards, regrip the packet in right-hand end grip, then pull the top card into left-hand dealer’s grip with the aid of your left thumb to display a Ten. This leaves you with a double card in your right hand. Turn your right hand palm up to display another Ten.
Give your audience a few seconds to process the double transformation before turning your right hand palm down and placing the double card sidejogged on top of the face-up Ten in your left hand. Temporarily clip the two cards, held as one, under your left thumb so you can regrip the double by its right long edge between your right fingers and thumb (thumb on top, fingers below). Gently flip the double face up, allowing it to fall on top of the card below it. Take the Ten being held by your participant with your left hand and drop it face up on top of the packet held in your right.
Perform a Mini-Ascanio Spread on the packet to clearly display three Tens before displacing the double card of the spread from the middle to the bottom of the packet. Regrip the packet from above in right-hand end grip. Reverse count the four cards as three, holding the last two cards as one.
To reset the trick, flip the packet face down and replace the packet in your right jacket pocket on top of the Joker already in there.
Developing the handling for the “Paradox of Love” brought to mind the classic gag effect called the “Tree of Hearts”. If you have the special card for this trick (a tree with lots of hearts growing on it), you can use it instead of the Ten of Hearts. By replacing the Joker with a blank-faced card, you can magically combine your two “hearts” with the one held by your participant to form the “Tree of Hearts.” To do this, perform another Flushtration Count directly after the first one to make them both disappear. Then continue on with the final sequence to clearly show that you have two blank-faced cards and one with a tree printed on it. The “Tree of Hearts” joke pairs well with the concept of the paradox of love because it emphasises that giving away love is the only way to make it grow (like a tree).
To further strengthen the script and justify the production of three Hearts, you could also discuss Robert Sternberg’s Triangular Theory of Love, which includes three components of love: intimacy, passion, and commitment. The tree represents what Sternberg calls consummate love.
| Sternberg’s Theory of Love explained in less than five minutes. Video Credit: Psych2Go via YouTube. |
You can also introduce the trick by stating that the deck is defective because three cards are blank and have not been printed, which may be a more compelling hook than using three Jokers. To clean up, give your participant the “Tree of Hearts” card as a gift, drop the other two cards on top of the pack, and shuffle the cards. The Ace of Heart will be lost in the deck.
If anyone cares to look, there will be three blank-faced cards in the pack—two left there after you perform the initial Braue Addition and one you returned at the end—when there should only be two. The simplest way to deal with this discrepancy is to remove the two blanks and the “two Jokers” (?) before you perform your next trick. Remove the three blanks and a single Joker (make sure you only have one Joker in your deck). You can even false count the cards to display them as two blanks and two Jokers, but I don't think that is necessary unless you want to practise your Elmsley Count on a five-card packet!
If you don’t have the specific gag card for this trick, fear not. You can easily craft one using a blank-faced playing card and some felt-tip pens. This personal touch adds a unique element to your performances. It allows you to gift the card as a one-of-a-kind keepsake each time you perform the effect, helping you foster a deeper and longer-lasting connection with your audience.
Final Thoughts
This trick gets excellent reactions despite its simplicity. Using a deck with three Jokers grabs people’s attention because most people—unless they’re avid card players, card collectors or magicians—have never seen three Jokers together in a deck. The multiple transformations become even more powerful when you connect them to the concept of the “paradox of love”, something that almost everyone can relate to.
Feel free to experiment with different interpretations of this trick. The real value here is the engaging presentational hook, not the method. For example, if you’re not keen on packet tricks, you could turn this into a full-deck trick. Begin by cutting to a Joker, then perform your favourite colour change to transform it into the Ace of Hearts. Switch this card for the Ten of Hearts. Cut to a second Joker and perform another colour change to turn it into the Ace of Hearts. Finally, show that the “love” you gave away has “grown” into the Ten of Hearts, creating a surprising and memorable experience for your audience.
Footnotes
- Magic Penny by Malvina Reynolds
Words and music by Malvina Reynolds. The song was copyrighted in 1955 and 1958 by Northern Music Corporation. It was later renewed in 1986. Despite the later copyright dates, this song was actually written while Malvina’s daughter was at a junior high school dance circa 1949.
Love is something if you give it away,
Give it away, give it away.
Love is something if you give it away,
You end up having more.It’s just like a magic penny,
Hold it tight, and you won’t have any.
Lend it, spend it, and you’ll have so many
They’ll roll all over the floor.For love is something if you give it away,
Give it away, give it away.
Love is something if you give it away,
You end up having more.Money’s dandy, and we like to use it,
But love is better if you don’t refuse it.
It’s a treasure, and you’ll never lose it
Unless you lock up your door.For love is something if you give it away,
Give it away, give it away.
Love is something if you give it away,
You end up having more.So let’s go dancing till the break of day,
And if there’s a piper, we can pay.
For love is something if you give it away,
You end up having more.For love is something if you give it away,
Give it away, give it away.
Love is something if you give it away,
You end up having more.

Comments
Post a Comment