High Card to Hell 🔥

This engaging narrative piece transforms a deceptively simple gambling demonstration into a rich theatrical experience. It’s an excellent choice for Halloween performances or as part of a bizarre magic act (a genre that often incorporates gothic storytelling and eerie elements to create a unique and memorable magical atmosphere).

You and two spectators reenact a traditional Scottish tale about a group of gamblers and the Devil. This faustian folk story, which typically ends with a moral lesson, has been modified to include a “magician versus the Devil” ending, a fun twist that adds a dramatic conclusion to the routine.

Image Credit: Marty's Bag of Tricks via Canva.

I prefer to use the core mechanics from the trick known as “Emerald Isle Aces” or “Revolving Aces” to perform “High Card to Hell”. However, any method that allows a spectator to cut to four-of-a-kind can, in theory, be adapted to fit the folklore-inspired presentation. In other words, it might be better to consider “High Card to Hell” a new premise and modified plot for Spectator Cuts to the Aces.

Effect

You begin by introducing a gambling game called “Cut the High Card” and invite two spectators to join you. The first spectator, though they don’t know it yet, will play the role of a mysterious stranger, while the second takes the part of an unlucky gambler. You position yourself as another gambler at the table.

The game starts innocently enough, with the first spectator cutting to the Seven of Clubs. Then your unlucky gambler cuts to three consecutive Sixes! This moment is when the friendly game takes a sharp turn, transforming into something darker. Now you reveal the true identity of the first spectator’s character—they’re the Devil in disguise! The signs were there: six-six-six, the Mark of the Beast! Unable to pay his debt, the Devil takes ownership of the gambler’s soul.

Then the stakes escalate. The Devil challenges anyone at the table to find all four Aces to win back the gambler’s soul. Should a person fail, the Devil will claim two souls as his prize! However, nobody but the Devil knows that the Ace of Clubs was removed from the deck before the game began, making the task seemingly impossible.

You then step forward, revealing yourself as not just another gambler but a world famous magician! With a confident smile, you proceed to locate three of the Aces in spectacular fashion. Finally, you transform the Seven of Clubs into the Ace of Clubs, beating the demon lord at his own game!

Background & Credits

The Spectator Cuts to the Aces plot was proposed by Bob Veeser in 1956 in a letter to Ed Marlo. The letter, which included three possible solutions, was just the beginning. Over the years, many magicians have developed their own versions of the plot. Some are self-working or semi-automatic, while others require a gaffed deck or setup. The ones that I find most interesting allow the spectator to cut and turn the cards over themselves. Later, kicker endings were added; not only were the four Aces found on top of each pile, but the four Kings were discovered on the bottom as well.

A similar premise, which involves the spectator cutting the deck into four packets and moving some cards from packet to packet, was published in The Dragon Magazine (Vol. 8, No. 6) in June 1939. This concept, created by Steve Belchou and originally called “A Four Aces Set Up”, was a significant contribution to the world of card magic. However, it is more commonly known as “A Poker Players Picnic” due to its uncredited inclusion in The Royal Road to Card Magic, a book that holds a special place in the history of card magic. Strictly speaking, the plot for “Belchou’s Aces” should be called “Spectator Locates the Four Aces”. However, from a layperson’s point of view, the end result is the same; most people don’t care whether the cards are cut or not.

“Revolving Aces”, first published in Close-Up Card Magic by Harry Lorayne in 1962, has a complicated history. A year earlier, the same trick was published in Genii Magazine (Vol. 25, May 1961, No. 9) under the more evocative title “Emerald Isle Aces”. The article, written by Faucett Ross, attributed the routine to Dai Vernon, and named it in honour of his Irish roots. (This edition of Genii was a special Irish issue, largely written and compiled by Hubert Lambert.) So, who created this trick, Vernon or Zarrow? Given that “Emerald Isle Aces” was the first of the two routines to see print, you’d naturally expect that one to be the original.

Well, a note by Stephen Minch in The Vernon Chronicles: Further Lost Inner Secrets clears things up. It mentions that the trick should be credited to Herb Zarrow, not Dai Vernon. There was an error in communication between Faucett Ross and Hubert Lambert when he was compiling the Irish issue of Genii. It was this that caused the correct credit to be “misplaced” (whatever that means). This error was further compounded when Lewis Ganson reprinted the trick in Ultimate Secrets of Card Magic with the wrong credit. But the mistakes didn’t end there. The king of plagiarism and original compiler of The Encyclopedia of Card Tricks, Glenn Gravatt, also published “Revolving Aces” as “Vernon’s Four-Ace Trick” in Fifty More Modern Card Tricks You Can Do (1979), further perpetuating the error.

Whether Vernon was really Irish is another matter. Approximately 10% of Americans claim to be Irish, which is a ridiculously high number. But was Dai Vernon one of them? Who knows?! 🍀

It should be noted that Herb Zarrow’s trick is, in essence, a version of the 203rd Force by Henry Christ repeated four times in a row without the use of a gaff. Henry Christ’s force using a double-backed card, which Theodore Annemann christened “The 203rd Force”, was first published in Annemann’s Sh-h-h--! It’s a Secret (1934, page 41).

Despite being over sixty years old, Herb Zarrow’s excellent trick still manages to deceive and entertain. I’ve found it works particularly well with this new presentation.

The inspiration for the presentation comes from a migratory legend known in academic circles as “The Card Players and the Devil”. In this tale, a group of young men play cards with a stranger who ultimately reveals himself to be the Devil in disguise. This legend is well-known in many European countries and has been classified under legend type ML 3015 by Norwegian folklorist Reidar Christiansen.

Requirements & Preparation

You only need a regular deck of playing cards to perform this trick. Remove the four Aces, the Seven of Clubs, Six of Hearts, Six of Spades, and Six of Diamonds from the pack.

Turn the Seven of Club face up and put it on top of the deck. On top of this, put the Six of Spades followed by the Ace of Hearts, both face up. Next, place the Ace of Spades, Ace of Diamonds, Ace of Clubs, Six of Diamonds, and Six of Hearts on top of the deck. These five cards should all be face down. The top card of the deck should be the Six of Hearts.

In summary, the cards should be in the following order (from the top of the deck down): 6H-6D-AC-AD-AS-AH-6S-7C. The Ace of Hearts, Six of Spades and Seven of Clubs should all be face up.

Method & Presentation

Perform a false overhand shuffle; see The Expert at the Card Table for details on how to do this. Follow this with your favourite false cut. Again, see Erdnase for some good blind cuts, as S.W. Erdnase calls them.

Put the cards in front of your first spectator, Doug. Tell Doug that he’ll be playing the part of a “handsome devil.” But not just any handsome devil, the dark lord of the underworld himself—Satan!

Instruct Doug to cut the cards “somewhere in the middle.” Once he’s done this, take the cut-off portion from Doug and carefully turn it face up. Casually spread through the cards, displaying that they’re well mixed. (Don’t spread too far, otherwise you might expose your stack.) Square them up and then drop the cards, still face up, on top of the talon on the table.

Continue your presentation by saying, “The Devil looked at his card and challenged the down-on-his-luck gambler to cut to a card higher than his. He promised that if the gambler won, he would grant him all his deepest wishes and desires. However, if he lost, the gambler’s soul would belong to the Devil!” Then, look at Harry and say, “Being a charitable demon, Satan gave the gambler three chances to win. That seems fair, right?”

Pick everything up and spread through the deck until you reach the first face-down card (the Seven of Clubs). Be careful not to spread too far; otherwise, you’ll expose the bank of face-up cards. Keeping it face down, drop the card to the table in front of Doug. This force uses the same mechanics as the 203rd Force, or the Christ Force by Henry Christ.

As you turn the face-up cards face down again, use your right thumb to injog the face card of the upper portion by a fraction of an inch. Once the cards are face down, press upward on the injog to create a break below the upper portion of the deck using your left little finger.

Next, perform a Double Undercut to return your setup to the top of the deck. You can now repeat the force on Harry, your second spectator.

Put the deck in front of Harry, who is playing the part of a degenerate gambler, and guide him through the actions of the Christ Force.

🔥 Hot Tip: After someone cuts some cards from the deck, I usually take them and turn them face up myself to avoid mishaps. However, if your participant is a confident card handler, they can perform the entire forcing procedure themselves.

Place the force card, the Six of Hearts, face down on the table in front of Harry. Repeat the Double Undercut before performing the Christ Force for a second time. Finally, execute yet another Double Undercut and repeat the force for a third and final time. Harry now has three face-down cards in front of him, setting the stage for the first climax of the trick.

Secretly bring the four Aces to the top of the deck, by performing one more Double Undercut.

Situation Check: The face-down Seven of Clubs is in front of Doug. The three face-down cards in front of Harry are the Six of Hearts, Six of Spades, and Six of Diamonds. The four Aces are on top of the deck in Club, Diamond, Spade, Heart order. The Ace of Hearts is face up, fourth from the top.

Tell Doug to turn over his card to reveal that he’s cut to a Seven, taking the card from him to display it more easily to the rest of your audience. Then instruct Harry to turn over his cards one at a time. As you gesture towards Harry’s cards, perform a Top Change to switch the Seven of Clubs for the Ace of Clubs, dropping the card on the table in front of Doug.

🔥 Hot Tip: If you’re worried Doug might be a troublemaker and look at his card prematurely, put it under an object, such as a drinking glass.

Turn to Doug and say, “The mysterious stranger let out a hideous laugh.” Look at Doug and wait for him to take the hint and giggle demonically. Continue by saying, “Six-Six-Six. The Mark of the Beast. The Devil now owned the gambler’s immortal soul!”

“The very handsome magician then asked the Devil to give his friend a chance to win back his soul. The Devil agreed to return the gambler’s soul if the magician could locate the four Aces. However, he warned that if the magician failed to find even one Ace, he would take two souls to hell that day. The magician, somewhat foolishly, agreed to the challenge.”

Cut the cards, then ribbon spread them across the table to display the Ace of Hearts face up in the middle of the deck. Cut the cards, bringing the Ace to the top. Deal it to the table in front of Doug with a triumphant look on your face. The production of the face-up Ace of Hearts from a spread hides the use of the Christ Force, making the previous cutting sequence very deceptive and difficult to back track.

Situation Check: The Ace of Spades is on the bottom of the deck. Above it is the Ace of Diamonds.

To produce the Ace of Spades, double-cut the bottom card of the deck to the top. Flip the top card over to reveal the Ace of Spades on top of the pack. I usually perform a Swing/Kick Cut followed by a Swivel Cut to transfer the Ace of Spades from the bottom to the top. 

Perform a standard Charlier Cut. As you complete the one-handed cut, it’s crucial that your left fingertips make contact with the Ace of Diamonds, the original bottom card of the deck. This action gives the illusion of pushing the card out from the centre of the deck. As the card emerges, curl your left fingers, causing the card to flip face up and land neatly on top of the deck. While this one-handed card production is a little knacky, it is worth the effort.

Turn to Doug and say, “A wicked smile spread across the Devil’s face as he exclaimed, ‘You still need to find the Ace of Clubs to save your friend’s soul!’ Then he let out another dreadful cackle.” Stare intently at Doug and wait for him to do his best evil laugh.

Continue by saying, “However, the devil was cheating; that dastardly demon had removed the Ace of Clubs from the deck!” Spread the cards to show that the Ace of Clubs is missing from the pack.

“Then something incredible happened. The magician smiled and shuffled the deck. He pointed the deck toward the face-down Seven and gave it a slow, deliberate riffle. When he turned over Doug’s card, it was revealed to have transformed into the Ace of Clubs!”

Conclude the routine by saying, “In a fit of rage, the Devil vanished up the chimney in a flash of fire and smoke.” Look at Doug expectantly and say, “Go on, then!”

Cleanup & Reset

The great thing about this trick is that it leaves you with a regular, shuffled deck. The reset isn’t instant, though arranging the eight-card setup on top of the deck won’t take too long if you need to repeat the effect.

Performance Tips & Additional Ideas

When performing for a single spectator, you might want to alter the presentation. In this situation, it makes more sense for you to play the part of the Devil in disguise and your participant to be the hapless gambler. You don’t even have to mention the Devil until the very end of the routine. You can then finish the trick by saying, “And that’s why some people call playing cards the Devil’s playthings!” This approach enables you to perform the routine without the story element, although I think the moral tale is what makes this routine shine.

There are also many different ways to handle the production of the four Aces. For example, once you’ve forced three Sixes onto your second participant, the four Aces will be on top of the deck. Three of the Aces are face down, while one is face up. This starting position is commonly found in many Four Ace Productions. You can easily adapt techniques from these production sequences to reveal two, three, or even all four Aces simultaneously. I’m particularly fond of “Riverboat Aces” by David Britland, which he shared via his Cardopolis Newsletter (issue #22). Here's the production in action:


A demonstration of "Riverboat Aces" by David Britland. Video Credit: Cardopolis Newsletter.

And here's the explanation video by David as well:


An explanation of "Riverboat Aces" by David Britland. Video Credit: Cardopolis Newsletter.

In fact, you can use any method for Spectator Cuts to the Aces to perform “High Card to Hell”. Here’s another method that I sometimes use. Arrange the eight cards in the following order (from the top of the deck down): AC-7C-6H-6S-6D-AH-AS-AD.

False shuffle the cards, retaining top stock. Then establish a little finger break below the top two cards of the deck (the best way to do this is to use the pinky count). Double cut these two cards, the Ace and Seven of Clubs, to the bottom of the deck.

Hand the pack to your first participant (the gambler), then instruct him to deal three piles as if he were playing a game of cards. Once he has dealt six cards (two cards to each pile), tell him that he can deal the cards out of order, or even deal more than one card at a time. Tell him to stop dealing whenever he wishes.

Take the remainder of the deck from him and ask another spectator (the Devil in disguise) to cut off some cards and place them on the table. Mark the cut by placing the remaining cards crosswise (at a slight angle) on top of the cut-off portion on the table. This is, of course, Max Holden’s Cross-Cut Force.

Next, pick up each of the three piles in turn and perform a slip shuffle, retaining the Six on the bottom and moving the Ace to the top. Count the cards in each pile by picking up the cards and dealing them back to the table. This does two things: it reverses the order of the cards, bringing the Six to the top and placing the Ace on the bottom. More importantly, it highlights the random way in which the piles were formed because there will, most likely, be a different number of cards in each pile. Alternatively, you could perform Paul Curry’s Swindle Shuffle at this point to further mix (?) the cards in each pile.

Situation Check: There is a Six on top of each pile and an Ace on the bottom. The Seven of Clubs is the lowermost card of the upper portion of the pile that was used to perform the Cross-Cut Force.

Display the Seven of Clubs as the cards that the Devil has cut to, holding the packet face up in left-hand dealer’s grip. As you do this, pinky count two cards to establish a little finger break below two cards (the Seven of Clubs and the Ace of Clubs below it). Lift the two cards, as one, off the packet in right-hand end grip. Rotate the cards remaining in left-hand dealer’s grip face down, then immediately lower the face-up double onto the packet, leaving it sidejogged and clipping it in place with your left thumb. After a suitable pause, flip the double card face down and deal the top card of the packet in front of your second helper. Place the cards remaining in your hand on top of the talon.

Turn the top card of each pile face up to reveal the three Sixes. Pick up each pile in turn and secretly switch the Six for the Ace on the bottom of each packet, as follows:

Perform a Pinky Pulldown to create a break above the Ace. Reposition the packet into right-hand end grip, transferring the break to the pad of your right thumb.

Next, pull the Six into your left hand, flipping it face down with the aid of the cards held in your right. Secretly unload the Ace on top of the Six as you turn your left hand palm down momentarily to display the face of the Six one last time.

Perform the Annemann Alignment Move to switch the Six for the Ace, leaving the Six on the bottom of the packet. Spin out the “Six” (actually an Ace) and drop it to the table in the space previously occupied by the pile. Drop the cards remaining in right-hand end grip on top of the talon.

Situation Check: The card in front of “the Devil” is supposed to be the Seven of Clubs. In reality, it is the Ace of Clubs. The three face-down cards in front of the participant playing the part of “the gambler” are meant to be the three Sixes, but are, in fact, the other three Aces.

Perform a magical gesture and then reveal that the four cards have transformed into the four Aces. You have beaten the Devil at his own game!

If you don’t want to transform the Sixes into the Aces, you can just turn each pile over to display the Ace on the bottom, then reveal that the Seven has transformed into the final Ace.

Final Thoughts

This trick features a compelling storyline, adding a fresh twist to the Spectator Cuts to the Aces plot.

When it comes to selecting a method, remember that the choice is entirely yours. If you don’t like my suggestions, that’s okay! You might want to consider exploring a simpler version of the plot, such as “A Poker Player’s Picnic” (“Belchou’s Aces”) from The Royal Road to Card Magic, especially if you’re just beginning your card magic adventures! Choose a method that feels suitable for your current skill level, then spend some time adapting the presentation to fit it.

You have the freedom to choose from the two methods presented here or use a different one that suits you better. I like using the mechanics of “Revolving Aces” because it allows you to cut to the cards directly, which aligns better with the “Cut the High Card” presentation. However, there are numerous other methods, each with unique advantages. For instance, some methods provide participants with a greater sense of agency by enabling them to shuffle, cut and deal the cards. I hope this trick inspires you to experiment and find a method that resonates with you and your personal style of magic.

Comments